Can’t find the right car? Let us look for you
Why Fair & Square
Our cars aren’t the cheapest on the market. Compare the complete value: the vehicle, documented preparation, clear costs and a local team after the sale.
We let our real customers do the talking — here's what they're saying on Google.
"Just picked up my 2015 Dodge Challenger Scat Pack and I couldn't be happier. Aydin and Andrew were upfront, and never made me feel pressured. If you're looking for a dealership that actually lives up to its name, Fair and Square Auto Group is the place to go."
"We purchased a Jeep for our twins' 16th birthday and they were both amazing! The purchase price was fair. Andrew went above and beyond to get the Jeep in gift-ready shape in less than 48 hours. They truly value their customers and being part of the community."
"The entire experience was outstanding — 5 star from start to finish. Andrew was honest, straightforward, and incredibly easy to work with. No hidden issues or inflated claims. Everything was fair and transparent. I wouldn't hesitate to buy from him again."
Why Fair & Square
The price you see is fair and upfront. Beyond it you'll only pay NY sales tax, title, registration/DMV fees, and a posted $175 documentation fee — no hidden back-office markups.
A available vehicle history history report is linked on nearly every listing — and if one isn't up yet, ask and we'll pull it. Look before you commit.
Good credit, bad credit, or no credit — our lender network shops for an approval that fits. Subject to lender approval; not all applicants qualify.
Our shop inspects and reconditions cars before they hit the lot, so you drive off confident.
How it works
Browse the lot online and check the available vehicle history on anything that catches your eye.
Send the secure 5-minute online application — a real person reviews it and follows up with you, usually the same business day.
Come down, drive it, and if it's right, we handle the DMV paperwork in-house.
Questions about a car, your trade or service? Ask our team before you decide.
Find your next car
Choose your next step below.
What Fair Deal means
Our approach to value: quality, preparation, and clear pricing. Fair Deal is our own brand promise, not an independent market-price rating. Review this vehicle’s condition, history, and current availability.
Choose a vehicle to see its published details and available next steps.
You don’t negotiate against us
Your local used car dealership in Islip Terrace, Long Island.
Financing for all credit situations is subject to lender approval.
See Our Reviews on Google (opens in new tab)For our Long Island neighbors
Shop at our Islip Terrace dealership, serving nearby East Islip, Bay Shore and Central Islip. Compare the vehicle, its history and the complete buying cost before you make the drive.
Looking for a commuter sedan or a family SUV? Start with your budget and needs, browse our filters, then confirm the specific vehicle's availability.
Browse used cars and SUVs →Ask for the history report, condition details and an itemized total. Our buyer checklist helps you prepare questions for your visit.
Read the buyer checklist →Share your vehicle's details for an appraisal request. You do not have to buy from us to sell to us; any firm offer follows our review.
Request an appraisal →Premium pricing. Personal service. Value you can understand.
At Fair & Square, our premium pricing reflects the care, vehicle preparation and personal service we provide before and after the sale. We explain the vehicle, the price, applicable fees and included benefits so you can compare the complete value with confidence.
A vehicle price is only part of the decision. Ask us about the preparation performed on the vehicle you choose, its available history report, and the services and benefits included with your purchase. Our team is here to explain your options and help with service after the sale.
Visit Fair & Square at 46–48 Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace, NY 11752.
Explore one vehicle at a time. Save a shortlist, compare the details and visit our local team.
Sell or trade — no obligation
Trading up or just selling? Tell us about your vehicle and we'll come back with a fair, no-pressure number — often the same day. You don't have to buy from us to sell to us.